Your inbox approves Men's coaches poll Women's coaches poll NFL draft hub
DALLAS COWBOYS
Ezekiel Elliott

What to expect from Ezekiel Elliott's appeals hearing on Tuesday

A.J. Perez
USA TODAY
Cowboys running back Ezekiel Elliott will try to get his six-game suspension reduced.

Ezekiel Elliott, as well as his lawyers and those from the NFL Players Association, will be at NFL headquarters on Tuesday in New York with one goal: Convincing an arbitrator to scrap — or at least reduce — the Dallas Cowboys running back's six-game ban. 

Former league executive Harold Henderson will hear the appeal of the suspension, which was issued by NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell on Aug. 11. 

Here's what to expect at the hearing and with the decision that will follow: 

What can Henderson consider at the appeals hearing?

Typically, an arbitrator will only be able to review the facts of an investigation. Those would be contained in the 160-page report generated by NFL investigators, who found "substantial and persuasive evidence supporting a finding that (Elliott) engaged in physical violence against" the alleged accuser. 

NFL DRAFT HUB: Latest NFL Draft mock drafts, news, live picks, grades and analysis.

The league also reviewed videos and photos of Elliott pulling down a woman’s shirt and exposing her breast during a St. Patrick’s Day parade party in March. That incident, the league wrote in its decision, showed a pattern “for which intervention is necessary for your personal and professional welfare.”

More:Cowboys star Ezekiel Elliott’s case too messy for comfort as suspension appeal nears

In pain:Which NFL teams are hurting most from preseason injuries?

"The arbitrator will review the evidence that the commissioner considered and rule whether it was a just punishment," David S. Weinstein, a former assistant U.S. attorney and current partner at the firm Clarke Silverglate, told USA TODAY Sports. 

Elliott will have a chance to address Henderson directly. 

What will Elliott and his reps argue?

Elliott denied that he ever assaulted his ex-girlfriend, who reported the alleged abuse to Columbus (Ohio) police in July 2016. Elliott was not arrested, and the local prosecutor's office chose not to file charges against Elliott. 

He is expected to introduce text-message exchanges between the accuser in an attempt to call the accuser's credibility into question.

USA TODAY Sports does not name alleged victims of domestic violence.

Other evidence will likely be presented to cast doubt on the accuser's accusations, including a Frisco (Texas) police report from September 2016, made public Monday, where Elliott accused the woman of harassment. 

What are the potential outcomes in the appeal?

There are basically three: The original suspension could be upheld, reduced or dismissed. There's no mechanism in place where Elliott could face a stiffer punishment.  

Elliott received the baseline six-game ban as part of the NFL's domestic violence policy, which was instituted in 2014 after then-Baltimore Ravens running back Ray Rice's assault of his then-fiancee and current wife.

For the suspension to be reduced, Weinstein said Elliott would have to show he did not engage in domestic violence, as the NFL contends. 

"The arbitrator could rule that Elliott still violated the personal-conduct policy, but not the portion that deals with domestic violence," Weinstein said. "That's about the only way he could get the suspension reduced."

How soon will a decision be handed down?

Article 46 of the collective bargaining agreement between the NFL and the NFLPA doesn't spell out a specific timetable for a decision, although one is expected before the start of the regular season. 

What are Elliott's legal options if the appeal doesn't go in his favor?

Elliott could seek a preliminary injunction in court, although the federal courts have already ruled that Goodell has the authority under the CBA to police player conduct. 

"Any hope for an injunction hinges on identifying a fundamental procedural error in a proceeding that has not yet occurred," sports attorney Daniel Wallach told USA TODAY Sports. 

 

Featured Weekly Ad